Sunrise on the Reaping Is Exciting and Hollow

Sunrise on the Reaping still of four kids dressed in black and white uniforms, walking.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping keeps that engrossing spark thanks to some emotional, weighty performances but struggles to stand alongside its peers.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is the second prequel in the franchise. This flick takes place during the 50th Quarter Quell, which had double the tributes. While entertaining overall, readers of the book might find bits lacking. Parts that felt essential to driving home the savagery and brutality of the games and those who push for its continued existence. Its PG rating harms it more. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping keeps that engrossing spark thanks to some emotional, weighty performances but struggles to stand alongside its peers.

Based on the book of the same name by Suzanne Collins, Francis Lawrence (The Long Walk, The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes) directs and Billy Ray (Animals, Terminator: Dark Fate) and Michael Lesslie (Now You See Me: Now You Don’t, Hamlet) write the script. It stars Joseph Zada (Invisible Boys, We Were Liars) as a young Haymitch Abernathy before grief, loss, and alcoholism turned him into a more jaded individual. Much of what happens mirrors the book’s events. However, due to condensing, many characters feel like a flash in the pan—here and gone before audiences can care. It still entertains. But much of what the book is trying to say becomes lost on screen. 

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Favors Quantity Over Quality

Sunrise on the Reaping still of Haymitch, played by Joseph Zada, kneeling while Maysilee, played by McKenna Grace, holds a tube.
Sunrise on the Reaping still. Photo Credit: Murray Close/Lionsgate.

Neither the cast nor moviegoers get to sit in a moment, taking it in, especially at the film’s start. Rather, it seems like a kaleidoscope of introductions. So, at times, the cast struggles to connect their characters to the larger story. Or, they have little opportunity with their diminished time. The relationship between Haymitch and fellow District 12 tributes Lou Lou—whom they never properly explain the existence of, played by Iona Bell (Fing!) and Wyatt, played by Ben Wang (The Long Walk, Brian), has no room to grow. So their tragic deaths do not land. Even Haymitch carrying Lou Lou does not matter enough because there was little between them before that scene. 

McKenna Grace’s (Gifted, Regretting You) Maysilee gets more screen time. But the mean girl’s permanent scowl on her face feels more like a caricature. They build the connection between her and Joseph Zada’s Haymitch. Unfortunately, she feels like she understands her character only in the most basic sense. Plus, it’s a shame the same cannot be said for Haymitch’s relationships with his mom and brother. Truthfully, I’m trying to remember if they even showed the pair’s faces directly to camera in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping . 

Some Amazing Performances Aid the Movie

Sunrise on the Reaping still of Kelving Harrison Jr. as Beetee holding his glasses up.
Kelvin Harrison Jr. as Beetee Latier in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. Photo Credit: Murray/Lionsgate.

Joseph Zada creates a Haymitch that’s easy to care about because his humanity and ability to see that quality in others make him exceptional. Despite trying, he’s incapable of hiding how he feels. Whitney Peak (Thrash, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina) gives the affection and fire her character, Lenore Dove, possesses as Haymitch’s girlfriend. The pair are adorable together. So The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is a mix of ‘A’ quality and ‘needs work.’ 

Next, Beetee, played by Kelvin Harrison Jr. (Chevalier, Mufasa: The Lion King), and his son, Ampert, played by Percy Daggs IV (Paradise, Never Let Go), have amazing performances. They are two you care about. Another memorable performance is Elle Fanning (Predator: Badlands, A Complete Unknown) as the effervescent Effie Trinket. So, it seems to be a mix of acting talent and screenplay/plot that creates these empty pockets of story in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.

Brutality and Empathy

Sunrise on the Reaping still of Lenore, played by Whitney Peak, staring at Haymithch, played by Joseph Zada.
Sunrise on the Reaping still. Photo Credit: Murray Close/Lionsgate.

The harsh deaths in the book balance out in particular with Haymitch’s empathy with his fellow tributes. Because, opponent or not, they are all meat in the game, and he understands that. So, even if he must fight, he remembers who is the villain pitting them against each other. Which is why Haymitch’s determination to make Snow, played by Ralph Fiennes (The Menu, 28 Years Later: The Bone Temple), own those horrors matters. But The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping loses sight of the book at times. 

There is a particular moment in the book when there are three tributes left that feels vital to the heart of the story and Haymitch. Unfortunately, it’s left out of the film, and they even offscreen one of the deaths. Many of the deaths in here feel lackluster because there is either no blood or they literally become drowned in special effects. Sadly, the earlier films were still able to make the deaths have weight while The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping struggles in that department. 

Worth Watching But If You Read the Book a Tad Frustrating

Sadly, rushed sections struggle to build relationships, save for a couple. So the bleakness of the book does not fully appear on the silver screen. And do not expect attention to see sponsors’ gifts, the tribute scores, or even much of the interviews. It happens in the book, but the movie clearly has enough on its hands. Even the focus on allyship feels lost.

The movie reminds me of a series that starts spectacularly, then slowly focuses on getting famous names on their series as the quality weakens. Sunrise on the Reaping is certainly fun, but it bypasses a deeper understanding, leaving many characters little more than meat in the game. And of the adaptations of the series, this is a diminished but nevertheless worthwhile watch for fans of the series.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *